False Prophets of Profit: How to Spot Modern Investment Schemes

Advancements in technology have significantly enhanced investment schemes over the years, making them more sophisticated and harder to detect. With so much information coming at us through the internet and social media platforms, it can be difficult to discern what’s real and what’s not online.

Everyone would like to earn an easy dollar or win the lottery (without ever buying a ticket). These quick earnings can be very enticing and seem completely plausible. However, it’s important to do our due diligence when considering nontraditional investments. A few prevalent and often costly investment-related cons to watch out for are the pump and dump, pyramid scams, and Ponzi schemes.

Pump-and-Dump Schemes: Wolves in Sheep’s Clothing

A pump-and-dump scheme involves fraudsters artificially inflating a stock’s price through false or misleading information, then selling their shares once the price peaks. The process is straightforward but often devastating for victims: actors “pump” up excitement around a typically low-volume stock, wait for unsuspecting investors to drive up the price, then “dump” their holdings for a quick profit.

When the selling begins, the stock price collapses, leaving legitimate investors with significant losses.

Fraudsters often pump up prices via social media accounts, where they impersonate financial influencers and begin promoting the stock across multiple platforms. The scheme typically targets three groups: new investors seeking quick gains, older adults less familiar with digital platforms, and individuals attracted to trendy investment themes like meme stocks or cryptocurrency.

The playbook usually follows a predictable pattern. Schemers first establish fake credibility by impersonating celebrities, financial professionals, or representatives from legitimate firms. They then invite potential victims into “exclusive” investment groups on platforms like WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, or Discord.

Once inside these groups, members share urgent stock “recommendations” with promises of immediate profits. Victims may even receive coaching on how to respond if a family member or friend raises questions about their investment decisions―a tactic that isolates them from others who could help shut down the scheme before it gets too far.

Pyramid Schemes: Building on Sinking Sand

While pump-and-dump schemes manipulate stock prices, pyramid scams operate through a different but equally destructive model. These represent a form of financial fraud where recruitment fees from newcomers fund payments to established members who successfully bring in additional participants.

These fraudulent operations are often disguised as legitimate business ventures. Promoters typically leverage digital channels―social media platforms, online advertisements, video content, etc.―to attract potential victims.

These schemes are inherently unsustainable and inevitably fail, leaving many participants with significant losses. Key characteristics of pyramid schemes to watch out for include:

• Promises of substantial profits within unrealistic timeframes
• Claims of income generation requiring minimal work
• Mandatory upfront investment or participation fees
• Convoluted compensation plans that obscure the true earning potential

The fundamental flaw in these schemes lies in their mathematical impossibility, since they require an endless supply of new recruits to sustain payments to existing members.

Ponzi Schemes: Robbing Peter to Pay Paul

Another common form of investment fraud operates by using new investor funds to pay returns to existing participants. These schemes derive their name from Charles Ponzi, who in the 1920s promised investors extraordinary 50% returns within months through what he claimed were investments in international postal coupons. In reality, Ponzi simply used money from newer investors to create the illusion of profits for earlier participants.

Modern Ponzi scheme operators typically promise exceptional returns with minimal or nonexistent risk―a combination that should immediately raise suspicion among faithful stewards. Rather than generating legitimate profits, these fraudsters rely on a continuous influx of new investment capital to maintain the illusion of success. They often pocket significant portions of incoming funds for personal use while using the remainder to pay fabricated returns to earlier investors.

Critical Warning Signs

Learning to recognize fraudulent schemes protects both your financial future and your peace of mind. The most dangerous red flags often appear together, creating an unmistakable pattern once you know what to look for.

The first major warning could involve unrealistic promises. When someone guarantees extraordinary returns or presents “can’t miss” opportunities, it’s a sign to approach with extreme caution. Think of the old adage, “If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.” Legitimate investments always carry risks, and no ethical advisor can promise certainty about the future. Schemers usually pair guarantees with artificial urgency, using phrases like “act now before it’s too late” or “limited time opportunity.” This language is meant to force you into a hasty decision and prevent you from conducting proper research.

The second concern is receiving investment advice from unknown sources, particularly through social media or messaging platforms. These communications often appear as if they’re from a credible source, but the sender lacks the accountability and credentials of a licensed financial advisor and is most likely not who they say they are.

Another serious red flag is when someone coaches you on what (or what not) to say to people close to you about the investment opportunity. Pay close attention if someone close to you mentions they have been contacted about an investment opportunity but can’t share the details―it could be a sign they have been targeted by a scammer.

What to Do if You’ve Been a Target

If you or someone you know has been the target of a fraud scheme, swift action is crucial. Here are a few steps you can take to address the situation:

• Stop all communication with the suspected fraudsters. Don’t send money or share account information, if you haven’t already.
• File a complaint. The Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC) has a website specifically for reporting investment schemes. Let the SEC know about the fraud at gov/tcr.
• Take protective measures. Let your financial advisor know you’ve been approached by someone you are unsure of. They can help watch your account(s) for any suspicious activity and let you know if any recent withdrawals have been made.
• Explore potential legal recourse. Securities litigation attorneys specialize in investment fraud. Many firms offer free consultations and work on contingency fee arrangements, meaning you only pay if they recover funds for you.

Walking in Wisdom

As with all financial decisions, it is important to seek God’s wisdom and guidance as you decide where to invest your funds. When investment opportunities seem too good to be true, they usually are. Take the time to verify information through independent sources and seek counsel from trusted financial professionals who share your values.

Remember that faithful stewardship requires both prudence and integrity. Legitimate investment opportunities don’t require secrecy, urgent action, or coaching on what to tell others. Professional investment advice comes with proper credentials, transparent communication, and an honest acknowledgement of the risks.

Related Resources:

• Are You at Risk for Financial Fraud? Here’s How to Protect Yourself.
• Could Financial Lies Be Keeping You from Discovering True Riches?
• Is My Cash Safe?

CAS00001878-06-25